A new Government, but will building safety finally change?

A new Prime Minister, Angela Rayner back as Housing Secretary and Baroness Judith Blake appointed as Labour’s fourth building safety minister: can leaseholders hope again? We’re trying to stay positive, but we’re disillusioned by what has happened – or to be accurate, not happened – since Labour came to power over two years ago and as we enter the tenth year since Grenfell.

This is a long read, but please do take the time to read it in full – you’ll probably want to get a cup of tea (or glass of wine).

Progress – at (the same glacial) pace

There were steps forward during Angela’s initial tenure at MHCLG. We welcomed the confirmation last July of remediation funding for social housing providers and for buildings under 11m although this felt like low-hanging fruit compared with the meaningful change Labour promised. But we liked Angela, as she seemed to understand the challenges she faced and spoke to us with compassion.

It’s probably best we say nothing about Steve “build, baby, build” Reed’s stint as Housing Secretary other than to note Ed Daffarn of Grenfell United’s view that Mr Reed was worse than Robert Jenrick, which certainly takes some doing.

It is clear that the drive to build 1.5 million homes has meant building safety has been deprioritised. Building safety remains part of a junior ministerial brief and we have seen the impact of this in the Remediation Bill proposals, which are just not good enough. They are too little, too late and will not make a difference to people’s lives any time soon.

An unfit-for-purpose Remediation Bill

Labour recognised this as a building safety crisis for years as well as in its manifesto, so it is particularly galling that the King’s Speech briefing notes reverted to calling it a “cladding safety crisis”. The Government says the Bill “will tackle those who are blocking remediation, restore confidence in the housing market, and make sure no building, and no resident, is left behind.” Our lived experience of the current system gives us no confidence that those promises will be met unless the Bill changes who controls delivery and closes the existing gaps.

MHCLG will trumpet its Legal Duty to Remediate and Remediation Backstop plans. However, the legal duty seems an implicit admission that Remediation Orders are ineffective. And the backstop proposals show how government’s rejection of the Housing Select Committee’s June 2020 call for Compulsory Purchase Orders – describing them as a “less attractive option to ensure pace” – was a serious mistake.

Plans to mandate the woeful PAS 9980 framework standard will mean people will not feel or be safe in their homes and insurance costs will stay sky high. The proposal to compel registration of 11-18 metre buildings looks set to fail to learn the lessons of the past with more costs to be forced onto leaseholders. There may be measures to make product manufacturers pay, but this must not be instead of protecting leaseholders – in any event, the “technical legal barriers” cited in the King’s Speech are a direct consequence of the Building Safety Act being poorly drafted in the first place!

The Government may say every building will be made safe and that people will be able to move on with their lives but, in its current form, the Bill will not do this: it will only entrench the financial and emotional damage.

The multitude of issues Labour spoke so strongly about in opposition remain unaddressed – whether in the Bill or, crucially, operationally on the ground. Too many promises have been made but not kept. The harm being caused to ordinary people continues unabated. Victims of this crisis are right to feel they have been betrayed.

The Remediation Bill risks being treated as the principal answer to issues that actually require immediate operational decisions. Legislation has a role, but it cannot substitute for firm operational grip now. Every month spent waiting for a future legislative solution is another month in which residents, leaseholders and shared owners remain trapped – facing attritional battles to find out if their homes are safe, and being battered emotionally and financially. The key question remains: What can the Government change now?

New ministers, the same unresolved issues

Over nine years after Grenfell, government’s response to the building safety crisis remains enormously – and unnecessarily – complicated and painfully slow. There are different funding schemes, different rules, different regulators, different responsible parties and different treatment of the same defects from one building to the next.

The Developer Remediation Contract has failed spectacularly to deliver the outcomes promised when it was first introduced. MHCLG has allowed the developers to mark their own homework without sufficiently transparent independent oversight or verification. And despite promises of commercial sanctions, there have been none.

Last year, Labour agreed a target for remediation to have started or completed on 80% of the developer buildings requiring work by the end of July 2026 ; however, the most recently published developer data – now over four months old – reports that only 48% had started or completed.

There are no consequences that would ensure leaseholders and shared owners in Developer Contract buildings have certainty. Where developers miss the target, the Government should immediately move buildings to grant funding and recover the cost from those developers. There have been occasional mentions of “special measures”, yet the Government has given no indication it is prepared to use the prohibitions in the Responsible Actors Scheme while it relies on the same developers to meet its housing target.

Homes England’s Cladding Safety Scheme (CSS) has been designed so that funding is granted for all intolerable external wall risks, which is a material improvement on the inconsistent and inadequate Building Safety Fund. Oversight measures and communication mechanisms are in place, so that residents, leaseholders and shared owners are at the centre, with improvements from lessons learned able to be implemented quickly. This grip of remediation in the CSS is what people desperately need at the Developer Contract buildings.

However, non-cladding defects remain unfunded in the CSS, so buildings are only made half-safe. Government officials pretend non-cladding defects are not delaying work despite having extensive evidence to the contrary. Taxpayer money has been wasted under the guise of “managing public money”.The focus has been on moving buildings from one MHCLG spreadsheet to another and hoping they have been made fully safe when this is too often far from the case.

Labour’s manifesto spoke of better protecting leaseholders from costs. But these were warm words, as there is still no respite for non-qualifying leaseholders, who were arbitrarily excluded from protection. Meanwhile, the majority of freeholders and head leaseholders are doing all they can to avoid their financial liabilities, leaving leaseholders and shared owners exposed.

Promises to consider whether the Government might support industry to reduce extortionate insurance bills were made in December 2024, yet there have only been more consultations and surveys and no intervention.

The merry-go-round of buck-passing continues.

The new ministerial team at MHCLG must hit the ground running. They need to show that they have the political will to take control of this horror show and take urgent action. We are tired of senior MHCLG officials – including some responsible for the existing approach – repeating why action cannot be taken, rather than focusing on finding ways to deliver it, and appearing resistant when that approach is challenged. Ministers must show leadership, grasp the nettle and direct their officials to do much, much more.

This culture in government must change. And it must change now.

What we still need

Our position remains that the Government must move towards a simplified, comprehensive and centrally driven approach to remediation, rooted in the principles of Labour’s former Building Works Agency proposal. We know the remediation landscape has changed, but the fundamental problem that solution sought to answer has not gone away.

If anything, years of additional schemes, unequal protections, complex and conflicting legislation, and piecemeal interventions have made the case for central operational control even stronger.

After nine years, ending this crisis should not require people to understand the boundaries between MHCLG teams, funding programmes, local authorities, regulators, developers, freeholders and recovery mechanisms. That is the Government’s job: to take control, protect people and repair the harm caused by decades of regulatory failure and the awful construction practices this enabled.

For residents, leaseholders and shared owners, the system must be simple.

  • Consistency in how buildings are assessed and made fully safe and sellable.
  • Control through central oversight and decisive intervention where responsible parties fail.
  • Accountability through transparent data and determined recovery of costs through levies, taxation and strategic litigation.

Only this would give people certainty and restore confidence in the housing market. There has been enough tinkering around the edges. Labour needs to take control of the system from beginning to end. No more excuses, no more deflection to local regulators, no more distant meaningless deadlines that are the result of guesswork rather than robust forecasts.

Will Prime Minister Burnham keep his promises?

In June, we wrote to Sir Keir Starmer and asked him to meet us so we could help Labour end this crisis. We received no response. That brings us to Prime Minister Burnham, a man who has supported our cause and recognised the sheer injustice we face since day one.

Following publication of the Grenfell Tower Inquiry phase 2 report in September 2024, the Prime Minister – then Mayor of Greater Manchester – said:

“This just isn’t right… a different approach has to be taken… You cannot leave people year after year… in a home where they’re going to sleep every night thinking, ‘Am I safe?’…I would ask the Government to consider that different approach.”

In July, the Prime Minister told the BBC that he “won’t change coming into this job” and wouldn’t “take different positions”. He must now show he has the political will to make his government take control. We hope Andy will agree to meet us soon.

Ahead of the Remediation Bill being introduced in Parliament, Baroness Pinnock of the Liberal Democrats has tabled a Leaseholder Remediation (Building Safety) Bill as a Private Members’ Bill in the House of Lords. You can read the briefing we sent to some peers here. The bill had its second reading on Friday 11th September, with agreement to proceed to the committee stage. Baroness Blake spoke on behalf of the Government. We appreciated her empathy, but it is fair to say that her speech mostly repeated the tired lines we have heard for years.

We’ll keep pushing the Labour government to finally give this crisis the attention it deserves so that it is no longer swept under the carpet.

But we need you to do your bit and keep the pressure on, because those who benefit from the status quo will certainly continue to lobby the Government.

CALL TO ACTION! 
Please email your MP as soon as possible using this template. If you copy us at endourcladdingscandal@gmail.com, it helps us track which MPs have been contacted. If you know your MP’s email address, you can send the email directly. If you don’t know your MP’s name or email address, use this online tool. It’s quick and easy! IMPORTANT: If you no longer live in the constituency where the affected property is located, please email the MP for your current address and explain that your property is in another constituency. 

Follow us on Twitter
for important updates on the campaign, ways to get involved and new information

Find out more about the End Our Cladding Scandal Campaign

You Might Also Like